How to Eat Salt Water Taffy - Tips for Maximum Enjoyment!

Salt water taffy is so much more than just candy—it’s an experience all wrapped up. You may remember it from a vacation along a New Jersey boardwalk, a candy shop you visited as a child, or just love the texture, there’s something special about unwrapping a fresh piece.

You can eat your salt water taffy any way you like - there's no wrong way! However, here are some tips to give you the maximum enjoyment.

FIRST STEP - Unwrap... The first step is to simply unwap the taffy - this is an obvious one :) Once you unwrap the taffy, you will notice that this is not your normal everyday taffy. This is a gourmet whippet taffy - giving you a softer texture that melts in your mouth.

STEP 2 - The Best Way to Eat Your Taffy Let it melt slightly before chewing. Salt water taffy isn’t meant to be rushed! Let it soften in your mouth for a moment to unlock its full flavor.

Chew vs. dissolve. Some people love the classic chew, while others prefer to let it melt completely for a smoother taste. Try both methods and see what you like best!

Mix and match flavors. Want to get creative? Pair two flavors together—like chocolate & ocange for that "Terry's Orange" kinda taste, or strawberry & bananna for a smoothie type experience.

STEP 3 - Taffy Etiquette & Storage Tips To keep your taffy fresh and at the perfect texture, follow these simple tips:

Handling Stickiness: If your taffy is too soft (especially in warm weather), pop it in the fridge for a few minutes. It’ll firm up just enough for the perfect chew.

Proper Storage: Keep taffy in a cool, dry place—avoid direct sunlight or heat, which can make it overly sticky.

Sharing is caring! Taffy is a fun, social candy that’s easy to pass around. Set up a flavor-tasting challenge with friends and see who can guess the flavors blindfolded!

Fum Ways to Eat Salt Water Taffy Want to take your taffy-eating game to the next level? Try these fun ideas:

Taffy & Coffee: Pair a piece with your morning coffee or hot cocoa for a sweet, melt-in-your-mouth moment.

Taffy in Desserts: Chop it up and mix it into cookies, brownies, or even homemade ice cream for a chewy, flavorful twist.

Taffy Tasting Party: Grab a mix of flavors and see who can guess the most correctly—blindfolds optional! No matter how you eat it, salt water taffy is all about fun. Whether you’re savoring it slowly or popping piece after piece, taffy is a treat that's meant to be enjoyed.